Thursday, July 3, 2014

Consistently Consistent (part one)

A few weeks ago, we had an issue here. 

Jason said something off-hand that hurt. He didn't mean to, but he accidentally touched a raw place of mine I was struggling with. He didn't know how I would react. Honestly, I didn't know how I would react. I quietly excused myself from the table, and a short while later, when he called my name, I went to him. He knew I was upset, but he was confused. He asked me why I was upset, and before I knew what was happening, the floodgates broke loose. I sat next to him on the couch, talking passionately, explaining why what he said hurt so badly, tears streaming down my face. He was completely blindsided, but could tell I was working myself up, so he stopped me as my voice began to raise in temper and said, "Go upstairs and calm yourself down." 

I obeyed him right away, went upstairs, cried some more and calmed down. I don't like feeling angry at him. I don't like how I feel when I am frustrated, and hurt. He is not the type to ever intentionally hurt me, so I also felt guilty. 

He is honestly very strict, so I expected when he came upstairs, he would spank me for getting so worked up and not controlling myself better. I'm expected to speak respectfully and with self-control. I thought I had been disrespectful, and my temper had gotten the better of me.

He came upstairs and immediately instructed me to kneel. I did. He explained how he didn't mean to hurt me, and that he understood why what he said was hurtful. He apologized. Then he said, "I am not spanking you for this. I was the reason you were upset. You didn't speak disrespectfully to me. You didn't disobey me. You came right upstairs when I told you to, so there is no need for me to discipline you." 

I was grateful he was being so understanding. I was also grateful I wasn't going to be punished. I don't like being punished. But my emotions were so bottled up, I remembered what it felt like back when I would question his discipline. I remember how badly I would crave his discipline, and how upset I would get when he would let things slide. 

But then I also remembered how he used to tell me, "If we do this, we do this my way." It didn't mean he didn't listen to me, or value my input. He always did. It meant that whether or not I would be disciplined wasn't up to me. And I was easily able to let it go, and put it behind us. 

He wasn't being inconsistent. 

He was being merciful. 

And isn't that his right to exercise as my Dom?

Once I accepted that mercy wasn't inconsistency, never again did I question whether or not I would be disciplined. There are times when I am disciplined and I don't agree. But I accept that he is the Hoh, and I listen to his reasoning, and try my very hardest to make sure I know why he disciplined me so that I don't do it again. I have always come to understand his point of view. There are times when I expect to be disciplined, and I'm not. But I am grateful he is merciful, and consider myself lucky that I got another chance to do it right. 

This is why I consider him to be exceptionally consistent. 

Consistency doesn't mean I am spanked for every little thing I do. It doesn't even mean I am spanked every time for the same thing. 

That's not what consistency is. It means he exercises his right to discipline when and how he sees fit. And he's the one in charge here. 

But I do think it's extremely important to note why consistency is vitally important in a D/S dynamic. Over and over and over again, in chats and forums and blogs, you hear Tih who are letdown by their husband's leniency. 


There is nothing that makes us feel more protected, cared for, and loved, than the certainty of a firm but loving hand. Those of us who crave this dynamic are wired that way. 

I'd like to explain another scenario we recently had here to illustrate my point. The second scenario did not, shall we say, end the same way my first scenario did. 

We have a rule here that I'm not allowed to speed. I used to drive like an absolute maniac, but those days are long gone. In the beginning, I would only be disciplined for intentionally speeding. If I caught myself speeding and slowed down, I wouldn't be punished. But that's not the rule anymore. Now, the expectation is that if I catch myself speeding, I need to confess, and I will be punished. 

Let's just's kinda of a really hard rule for me, and I'm really not "there" yet. Mostly I've made a habit of driving cautiously, but when I get distracted, at times I lose my focus and catch myself speeding.

Recently, I was on a long trip without him, visiting some family. I made the trip there just fine, obeyed the traffic laws, my phone rules, everything. But while I was there, I got some disturbing news. I got into a discussion that brought back some was an unexpectedly emotionally intense afternoon. On the way home, my mind was elsewhere. I was terribly distracted. 

I caught myself speeding three times. 

Jason wasn't home when I got home. My stomach was in knots. I hate confessing and prefer to have it over as soon as possible. I was saddened knowing I'd disappointed him. I knew without a doubt he would spank me.

He came home, and I told him I had to talk to him. He gave me a kiss, said it was time to put kids to bed, but that we would talk as soon as we had time alone. 

When he called me to him, I went in, knelt by him, and told him, "I caught myself speeding three times on the way home. I'm not trying to get out of being punished, but I wanted to explain what happened." 

He nodded. "Tell me what happened." 

So I explained the situation, what I had heard when I was up there, and why I was so distracted driving home. During my explanation, he was completely empathetic, asked about certain things that happened, and told me he was sorry about the news I got and the afternoon I had.

Then he stopped talking and looked meditative. 

"What are you thinking?" I asked him quietly. He looked to me, and very gently put his hand under my chin."I think I need to spank you, because you broke a rule, and a safety one at that. But I also think that given the circumstances, I'm not going to punish you severely." 

I nodded, and buried my head in his lap. 

He was exercising consistency.  And it made me feel loved. 

I didn't look forward to being disciplined. Even though I do like to be spanked (for other reasons), the emotional impact of being disciplined makes it very unpleasant. Plus, he really makes sure punishment spankings count. 

It's actually pretty rare that he metes out discipline with gentle understanding the way he did that night. When the time came for him to discipline me, the word "gentle" doesn't exactly come to mind -- he made his point alright, and I did, in fact, catch myself speeding the following week and he did, in fact, spank me soundly for it. 

But I consented to this lifestyle for a reason. It was far deeper than merely an erotic attraction. If  that's all there was to it, we never would've gone beyond sexy spanking in bed. It's more than just a game. My obedience to him, and his leadership, are things we both work on constantly. And though I dislike being punished, it cannot be denied that the punishment aspect of a d/s relationship is one of the many things that make it work. 

And this is why consistency is so important. It shows me that he takes his role, and mine, seriously. 

When he disciplines me for doing something unsafe, I know he wants me to take care of myself, because he loves me. When he spanks me for losing my patience, I know he's teaching me to be a better person. When he punishes me for speaking rudely to him, I know he does so because he values harmony in our relationship. When he swats my rear for a self-deprecating remark, I know he wants me to be gentle with myself. 

It takes great strength to allow yourself to live this dynamic. When you willingly choose either role -- whether you are the one in authority, or you are the one relinquishing control -- you choose vulnerability. The choice to be transparent and vulnerable takes great courage, because you run the risk of being hurt. 

So even though being punished is certainly unpleasant -- it is, after all, meant to deter -- a consistent adherence to the expectations is crucial. With consistency, the submissive knows the trust she has given is cherished. She knows her efforts are not in vain. With consistency, the Dom understands that he has been given tremendous responsibility. It is with consistency that the Dom grows confident in his role.

When Jason takes the time to instruct me, I know the values he and I hold true mean something. When he disciplines me I know he does so because he firmly believes it is for my own good. It has become clear, as we took the plunge and incorporated d/s into our relationship at a deeper level, how well this dynamic works for the two of us. There is peace, and harmony. We still have disagreements. We still make mistakes. But problems are solved rapidly. We have both grown to trust each other more. We've both become more in tune to the needs of the other. 

So even though punishment is largely unpleasant, it's a facet of our dynamic that makes this work. When I willingly lay myself over his lap to be disciplined, it shows him that I trust him. I have the strength to submit, and he has the strength to exercise self control and fairness when meting out discipline. I feel that our relationship, our family, our values are important to him. 

But most of all? I feel like I am important to him. 

Although I am only speaking from personal experience here, I have attempted to draw from the thoughts and feelings of others in the community as well while elaborating on the importance of consistency. I feel I've barely scratched the surface, so I would love to hear from readers as well. 

What are your thoughts on consistency? What have been your own experiences, struggles, and conclusions? 


  1. I guess the biggest difference here and from struggles I've had and heard from others is that you and Jason are discussing each incident and his decision. It's the ignoring-the-issue-inconsistency which is particularly hard for me. Ultimately I want to know that he is paying attention, and when, and what he is noticing.

    I should show this to my husband in a "careful what you ask for" sort of way.

    1. Ah, yes. "What if he doesn't notice." That is a really good point. Stay tuned for another post. Not that I know all there is to know (I so do not!) but I think this topic is worthy of a discussion all its own.

  2. I see consistency much the same as you explained it. Leah did have a good point though. There's times I feel as though the issue has been ignored. However! The transparency and vulnerability must come into play at those moments. It's hard in the moment to not get caught up feeling like he's ignored or being inconsistent, but I'm forcing myself more and more to swallow my fears and pride and go to him. Maybe he didn't see the entire situation. So we talk it out and I ask. What was his perception of the incident, what should I do differently or avoid all together. I take his feedback for the next time. I let it lead me in the way I handle things in the future.

    1. Yes! There are moments of serious frustration, and we can use those as opportunities to communicate and learn what they want from us, how to go about approaching the situation in the future, etc.

      However, how to address those needs and concerns without topping or controlling? Mulling this over...

  3. This is a very timely post for me. I have been struggling lately because there is very little alone time between my husband and myself since school got out. I went from being spanked almost daily, to maybe once every couple weeks. I don't mind that so much, but along with that comes feelings of drifting....of uncertainty at times. He is always in charge and he makes sure I'm well aware, dominates me with words and actions other than spanking. But consistency in discipline is so important.

    1. I'm in the same boat River. My husband and I are both in the school system so we have the whole family off together for two months. The kids are old enough to go to bed at 11 pm so we have very little alone time. Mornings are good I guess but I understand where you are coming from. There is always at least one child at home.

    2. I well know that feeling of drifting. Jason and I call it "being put in my place." Over time, we've come to find ways to deal with that. At times, it's not a spanking but a private reminder of who's in charge. However, we've instituted a nightly check-in that goes hand-in-hand with our morning check-in. We almost always have all our kids at home (we have a large family) so we have a routine where we spend some time together and have told our kids it's our time to be alone. We go upstairs and they are on the other side of the house and if he needs to spank me, he does.

      We also have a code. I say "my tank is empty" and he knows I need him.

      We do have some silent implements and that really helps as well but....those are serious and NOT fun!

      It's hard managing privacy when privacy is at a premium, and really this dynamic does take quite a bit of time together.

    3. *Meaning, when I'm drifting he needs to "put me back."

  4. From under our roof, I agree with Leah on the differentiating between types of inconsistency. In our house it is the ignoring the incident that causes the most issues here. Unlike what Coral said, it isn't a case any more of him not seeing what I did- although goodness we went through that too, ( and talked every night for 5 minutes about how we saw our dynamic that day, which helped). Sometimes these incidents are out and out, black and white, in your face and.... nothing. Of course eventually we talk it out. But here at our house, those are the types of inconsistency we face. Sometimes yes, a great deal of times no- or a comment about it and then nothing.

    Those types of situations have me feeling like a yo yo emotionally. The times where he explains why he isn't going to spank, those are fantastic ( LOL on so many levels) but mostly because I know where I stand ( even though I won't have I know where he stands and to me that is the leader coming out.

    I absolutely LOVE this paragraph
    "When he disciplines me for doing something unsafe, I know he wants me to take care of myself, because he loves me. When he spanks me for losing my patience, I know he's teaching me to be a better person. When he punishes me for speaking rudely to him, I know he does so because he values harmony in our relationship. When he swats my rear for a self-deprecating remark, I know he wants me to be gentle with myself. "

    Barney often struggles with what he deems as being 'nice' or a nice guy. I constantly remind him that inconsistency in the way I mentioned above isn't being 'nice'- it is hurtful. Why? because it is the reverse to everything you said in the above paragraph. Your post couldn't be more timely !


    1. Hi, Willie. Thanks for stopping by!

      I completely understand what you mean by the two different types of consistency. I will write my thoughts on the other type of consistency shortly (hopefully this week).

      I completely understand what you mean about how the "nice" approach is hurtful. I used to say to Jason, "I need you to boss me around a little!" and then when he would I would say, "Ah, that's better." Lol

      You two raise some very good points. Thank you.

  5. You write with a lot of love about your husband. You are a lucky woman and it is so nice to see that you recognize that. I like the idea of choosing vulnerability because it brings about the closeness. Thank you for coming back to writing.

  6. Cygnet,
    Thank you for your comment. I absolutely adore Jason...he's so good to me. I try to avoid the "gushing" kinda posts but what can you do, sometimes they surface too. :)

    This dynamic has brought out the best in us, and I love what it's done for our marriage. I want to keep writing, because I want to see others experience what we have, too.

    Thank you.

  7. Over the past two plus years consistancy has been an issue for us a lot-Clark really struggled with following through when punishment was needed at times when he wasn't viewing the "crime" as being "all that bad", meaning not a safety issue-he has since come to realize how important all the rules are that we have in place & how consistently letting "the little things" go made it seem less like mercy & like more of a cop out. I was finally able to explain to him (respectfully) how let down I felt by what he was looking at as mercy because we had spent time & effort to talk about & come up with our rules & when he would just not enforce them it felt like it had been a waste of time. As he has gotten more confident is his role he has had a easier time enforcing the rules on a regular basis so that when he does give mercy now that is exactly what it feels like & I am thankful & not frustrated by his decision.
    Scarlet ; )


Thanks for stopping by! We'd love to hear from you.

Dissenting comments are welcome but please, be polite. Any rude or slanderous comments will not be published.